Categories: News

Coordination games vs prisoner’s dilemma in sustainability games: A critique of recent contributions and a discussion of policy implications

A new publication by Pietro Manfredi and co-authors published in Ecological Economics.

Coordination games vs prisoner’s dilemma in sustainability games: A critique of recent contributions and a discussion of policy implications

Abstract

Recent works have suggested that most games arising in climate change diplomacy and sustainability choices, should have a coordinative nature rather than that of a prisoners’ dilemma, as typically suggested. In this note, after having proposed a definition of sustainability game, the authors critically review the merits and shortcomings of these contributions and use a simple, yet sufficiently general, model to recall the difficulties for coordination to emerge in such games. Indeed, as far as the players’ short-term interest is involved, at least in some degree, these games will most often generate a prisoner’s dilemma, thereby allowing coordination only upon long-term interactions possibly under the pressure of a continuing environmental deterioration. A counter- intuitive result is proved, showing the circumstances when the deterioration of the environment can hinder cooperation in repeated games. The authors conclude by highlighting a number of factors forcing “brown” behaviour and therefore threatening coordination, first of all poverty and inequality, and pinpointing that, though ability to enact coordination will be key for a successful battle for climate, undue emphasis on coordination might be the deleterious in view of its optimistic message.

The article is available online here.

REMARC

Recent Posts

New Publication: Unseen costs: the inequities of the geography of innovation

Ron Boschma, Rune Dahl Fitjar, Elisa Giuliani and Simona Iammarino have published their article Unseen…

2 months ago

New Publication: Banks and human rights: what do we know?

Elisa Giuliani, Chiara Macchi, Federica Nieri and Verdiana Morreale have published their article Banks and…

2 months ago

New Publication: Inference for big data assisted by small area methods: an application on sustainable development goals sensitivity of enterprises in Italy

Francesco Schirripa Spagnolo, Gaia Bertarelli, Donato Summa, Monica Scannapieco, Monica Pratesi, Stefano Marchetti and Nicola…

4 months ago

Living in the ‘doughnut’: Reconsidering the boundaries via composite indicators

Da alcuni anni sta guadagnando popolarità l’“economia della ciambella” (Doughnut Economics), proposta dall’economista britannica Kate…

4 months ago

Call for papers – YSI Workshop on the Macroeconomic challenges of the green transition II

The Keynesian Working Group is happy to announce a call for papers to the YSI…

7 months ago

New Prize: A nested error regression model with high-dimensional parameter for small area estimation

The 2024 Hukum Chandra Memorial Prize selection committee unanimously agreed to award Dr. Nicola Salvati,…

7 months ago