A new publication by Pietro Manfredi and co-authors published in Ecological Economics.
Coordination games vs prisoner’s dilemma in sustainability games: A critique of recent contributions and a discussion of policy implications
Abstract
Recent works have suggested that most games arising in climate change diplomacy and sustainability choices, should have a coordinative nature rather than that of a prisoners’ dilemma, as typically suggested. In this note, after having proposed a definition of sustainability game, the authors critically review the merits and shortcomings of these contributions and use a simple, yet sufficiently general, model to recall the difficulties for coordination to emerge in such games. Indeed, as far as the players’ short-term interest is involved, at least in some degree, these games will most often generate a prisoner’s dilemma, thereby allowing coordination only upon long-term interactions possibly under the pressure of a continuing environmental deterioration. A counter- intuitive result is proved, showing the circumstances when the deterioration of the environment can hinder cooperation in repeated games. The authors conclude by highlighting a number of factors forcing “brown” behaviour and therefore threatening coordination, first of all poverty and inequality, and pinpointing that, though ability to enact coordination will be key for a successful battle for climate, undue emphasis on coordination might be the deleterious in view of its optimistic message.
The article is available online here.
Elisa Giuliani has published her new article "Making it right: socio-environmental conditionalities in regional industrial…
Carolina Castaldi, Elisa Giuliani, Margaret Kyle and Alessandro Nuvolari have published their new article "Are…
Vicente Rios, Mercedes Beltrán-Esteve, Lisa Gianmoena, Jesús Peiró-Palomino and Andrés J Picazo-Tadeo have published their new article…
Giulia Romano and Lucio Masserini have published their new study "Pay-as-you-throw tariff and sustainable urban…
Yannick T. Wiessner, Elisa Giuliani, Frank Wijen and Jonathan Doh have published their article "Towards…
Elena Bruno, Giuseppina Iacoviello and Caterina Giannetti have published their article "Bank credit loss and…